Philip Hammond: My right hon. Friend is nothing if not persistent and consistent. I cannot remember how many times he has raised this issue. There have been numerous requests for new VAT reliefs since the referendum, some of which are currently not permitted under EU law. We have calculated that if we were to grant all the VAT relief requests that we have received, that would come to more than £38 billion a year. On VAT and tourism, the Government have received representations on this issue, and we are looking again at the case for change. We have issued a call for evidence on the impact of VAT  and air passenger duty on tourism in Northern Ireland, and we will certainly keep this issue under careful review.